John's Investment Book Recommendations

These are some of the best books on investing that I've read. I've listed them alphabetically by author, and included my comments on them. I'd say my biggest favorites are O'Neil and Lynch, though the Motley Fools books are an entertaining read. Here's a more complete list of investment books, most of which I haven't read. You can buy any of the books listed at a discount (from Amazon) by clicking on the title.

Wade Cook
Wall Street Money Machine

Wade Cook is a an ex-New York cab driver who hit it big first by working hard as a cab driver, then in the real estate market, and now he makes most of his money by going around giving expensive seminars on how to make money in the stock market. He's the current king of the get rich quick on Wall Street investment book authors, and this is one of his more popular books.

To be fair, he makes it clear in more recent books that he thinks you should invest most of your money conservatively and only use his get rich tricks on a small percentage of your portfolio. That said, most of his books describe agressive strategies that can make you (or lose you) a lot of money in the stock market in a short period of time. He particularly hypes two techniques: buying options on stocks that are about to split, and buying low priced stocks and selling options on them. His books are an entertaining read and make clear that it's possible to beat the market by a sizeable margin with the strategies he lays out. He's a little light on making clear the high amount of risk involved, so he's been taking a lot of heat on the net recently by people who lost their whole bankrolls on his strategies.

David & Tom Gardner (The Motley Fools)
The Motley Fool Investment Guide

Benjamin Graham
The Intelligent Investor

Benjamin Graham was known as the father of value investing, and he was also one of the pioneers in analysis (he died in 1976). His strategy is to base your selection of stocks strictly on automated, measurable criteria (as opposed to "feeling good about a company"). Basically, Graham says to look at both the business valuation (book value biased by earnings) and the stock market valuation (or stock price) of a stock, and choose stocks where the price is lower than the book. The bigger the difference between the two, the bigger your Margin of Safety for the stock's performance to slip without the price slipping.

Graham's most famous book was one he co-wrote with David Dodd called Security Analysis. It's much deeper in it's mathematics, and seems to be intended as a textbook on analyzing stocks, as opposed to The Intelligent Investor, which is written for the general public.

Peter Lynch
One Up On Wall Street

Burton Malkiel
A Random Walk Down Wall Street

Burton Malkiel makes the outrageous claim that "a blindfolded monkey throwing darts at a newspaper's financial pages could select a portfolio that would do just as well as one carefully selected by the experts." The basis for this claim is that it's impossible to predict the direction any particular stock (or the market in general) is going to head in the short term. Thus the direction of stock prices are a random walk.

This book has an interesting historical background on the way people have invested in past, with a particular focus on the mistakes they have made. He sort divides investors into those who invest based on firm foundations and those who build castles in the air. The former, of course, refers to the value type of investor, who bases their investments on things like P/E ratios. The latter refers to people who look for investments with a lot of hype, which generally are overpriced and run up to insane levels before collapsing (the idea being to get in when it's just starting to ramp up and get out before it crashes).

After describing both of these investment strategies, and historical background of their application, he goes on to assert that neither of them works worth a damn. Unfortunately, despite his prestigious position (he's an economics professor at Princeton), most of his refutations aren't well supported in the book. He mentions scientific studies to support his claims, but he doesn't cite most of the studies or give details of their setup, controls, etc. Granted, the book is for the general public, and they're not going to want to get into heavy statistics or economic arguments, but he could have at least cited the exact studies so the skeptical could check them out.

Steven L. Mintz,
Beyond Wall Street: The Art of Investing

William J. O'Neil
How to Make Money in Stocks :
A Winning System in Good Times or Bad

Okay, so most of the book is hype for the daily newspaper O'Neil produces, The Investor's Business Daily. It's still a good book that discusses ways in which the individual investor can do as well (or even better) by making his own decisions rather than buying mutual funds or having a broker or professional money manager make his investment decisions. The key to O'Neil's system is what he calls the "CAN SLIM" system:

Thus, his system is to look for stocks with good earnings, good relative strength, a low market capitalization, a little industrial sponsorship (but not too much), and something new going for it, but only during bull markets. The newspaper really accentuates his system by putting two figures in their daily stock tables that no other paper has: earnings per share rank and relative strength rank. The two things that take any effort to find in his system are the 'N' and the 'M'. It takes a bit to find out about new developments in a company before the price takes it into account, but not all stocks skyrocket immediately on good news. Also, despite his encouraging words, we all know that noone can succeed at timing the market consistently. I think this is one of the best books for someone who is looking for a system for growth investing.

James O'Shaughnessy
How To Retire Rich

A few years back, O'Shaughnessy was granted access 30 years of S&P's Compustat database, and he did a massive comparison of 15 different major strategies used in choosing stocks, along with various combinations and twists. In the book What Works on Wall Street, he tests this theory over all stocks over the whole 30 year period and presents a series of tables and graphs to show which ones have performed the best over time. To spoil the ending, the best strategy was choosing a portfolio of stocks with price to sales ratios of less than 1 with high relative strength. This method produced almost 19% annualized return over the whole 30 year period.

In How to Retire Rich, O'Shaughnessy distills the best information from that book to create a book that's written for the general public (as opposed to academics). Along with the standard rambling about why John Q. Public should invest in stocks instead of a savings account, he presents some of the best strategies from the previous book, and slight variations (including the popular Dogs of the Dow strategy). He also talks about whether to invest in bonds and so forth, but the meat of this book is in the strategies, the top of which is the aforementioned price to sales strategy under the guise of "Reasonable Runaways".

Here's a few more general books about investing that I like:

return to John's Investment Page
go to John's Investment Story
go to John's Stock Picks
return to John's Home Page